We use cookies to ensure that we give the best experience on our website. By continuing to use this site, you agree that we will store and use cookies on your device. You can revoke your consent at any time by deleting your saved cookies. Read more

Minimising the humanitarian impact of immigration detention: Time to promote alternatives

On International Migrants Day, 18 December 2020, the Red Cross EU Office (RC EU Office) calls on the European Union (EU) and its Member States to limit the use of detention in the implementation of migration policies.

Recently proposed legislative instruments under the new Pact on Migration and Asylum risk further expanding immigration detention. This overlooks its long-lasting negative impacts on people’s mental health and well-being. Worryingly enough, public health concerns triggered by the COVID-19 pandemic have also been used as an excuse for detaining migrants. Against this backdrop, the RC EU Office reiterate that liberty should be the norm. If there are grounds for restricting it, alternatives to detention should be considered first.

With the new Pact on Migration and Asylum, the RC EU Office fears that Member States will increasingly resort to detaining migrants. Notably, the new Screening Regulation as well as the additional amendments introduced in the 2016 proposal for a Recast Reception Conditions Directive and the 2018 proposal for a Recast Return Directive foresee the use of detention at borders and in the territory of Member States. Moreover, this proposal includes a new detention ground (risk to public security or national security). While immigration detention should be envisaged as a last resort, these developments are likely to exacerbate its use.

As providers of humanitarian services in the context of immigration detention, National Red Cross Societies in the EU regularly witness the impact of detaining migrants on their well-being and integration prospects. Drawing from the operational experience of the International Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement, the RC EU Office calls for detention not to be used as a tool to manage irregular migration. If there are any grounds for depriving migrants of their liberty, RC EU Office promotes developing and implementing alternatives to detention.

Alternatives to detention must not be other forms of detention, though. They should be proportionate, necessary, the least restrictive and allow migrants to live in the community. Although many Member States do have alternatives to detention, they are often not applied in practice. This is having a serious impact on migrants in the EU, particularly when they have already been made vulnerable by unsafe journeys.

As the EU is defining the future priorities of its asylum and migration policies, RC EU Office appeal to decision-makers to ensure that migration is managed in a humane way. The negative and long-lasting effects of detention on the physical and mental health of migrants should not be underestimated. Even relatively short periods of detention can have adverse consequences on migrants, particularly children and other vulnerable groups. Also, when migrants are deprived of their liberty on what they perceive as arbitrary grounds, this often triggers distrust towards the authorities and migration management systems. This in turn reduces compliance with immigration and case resolution processes.

Decisive action should be taken to make sure that immigration detention truly remains a last resort, and that irregular entry is not criminalised including for the purpose of seeking international protection. The RC EU Office calls on the EU and Member States to ensure that children and other vulnerable migrants are never detained.

Read more about the Red Cross and Red Crescent work on migration in Europe.

Tev varētu arī interēsēt:

Soldiers of the NATO Slovakian contingent and eFP BG who are stationed in Latvia donates food parcel to the Red Cross

On September 13, representatives of the Slovakian Army and NATO enhanced Forward Presence Battle Group Latvia donated more than 400 food parcels to social centre "Gaizins"

Representatives of NATO’s Italian army wish to be socially active and support children

This autumn, an activity will be organized to support the children of LatRC social centers.

Hepatitis Day – express testing in LatRC Health centers

04.08 2021 Health promotion
Within the World Hepatitis day on 28 July, from 26 to 30 July, everyone was invited to check their health free of charge by performing a hepatitis express test in the Latvian Red Cross Health centers in Riga and Daugavpils. In Riga 64 persons participated in express testing, of which hepatitis C was detected in …

Information about Dry Eye Disease (DED)

29.06 2021 LatRC Youth
Dry Eye Disease (DED) is a major and increasing health-care problem due to its high prevalence and economic burden. Prevalence data reveals that 5 to 35% of the world's adult population suffer from DED.

International Voluntary Services: New Memorandum of Understanding signed with the Latvian Red Cross

With the signing of a Memorandum of Understanding between the Latvian Red Cross and the German Red Cross, both national societies contribute to strengthening their cooperation.

A new campaign is launched to help the world’s mothers caught in war

On the occasion of Mother’s Day, RC is launching a new campaign to highlight the courage of women living in countries in conflict.